The Overheating Spiral in NHS Strategy Development
Understanding how command-and-control creates failure demand, friction, and waste
The Overheating Spiral in NHS Strategy Development
The Overheating Spiral is a self-reinforcing cycle where strategy development processes generate friction, which slows progress, which creates more friction, until the process itself becomes the problem. It's a systems thinking concept that explains why Public Sector strategy development consistently fails despite good intentions and professional execution.
What Is the Overheating Spiral?
Many leaders recognise the symptoms: persistent operational challenges, declining staff morale, and initiatives that stall. But what's the underlying cause? The Overheating Spiral explains how well-intentioned 'Command & Control' in complex systems can inadvertently fuel a cycle of inefficiency, friction, and waste. Watch the video above to see the spiral explained.
The Overheating Spiral describes how command-and-control approaches to strategy development create failure demand, friction, and waste:
The Cycle:
- Command-and-Control Approach: Top-down strategy development
- Failure Demand Created: Stakeholders don't feel heard, so they create additional work
- Friction Increases: More reviews, more revisions, more meetings
- Progress Slows: Strategy development takes longer
- More Friction: Slower progress creates more frustration, more resistance
- Spiral Continues: The cycle reinforces itself, getting worse over time
The Result: Strategy development processes that consume months or years, produce Frankenstein Documents, and fail to drive change.
The Three Friction Points
The Overheating Spiral manifests through three critical friction points:
1. Frankenstein Documents
Strategies written by committee, edited by committee, and disconnected from the people who need to implement them. Multiple authors, no single voice. Competing priorities stitched together. Language that sounds professional but lacks meaning.
The Friction: Documents that no one owns, so no one implements them.
2. £80,000 in Wasted Time
Strategy development processes that drag on for 6-12 months, consuming thousands of hours of executive time. Multiple rounds of review, revision, and re-review create a batch-and-queue system where nothing moves forward efficiently.
The Friction: Time wasted on non-value-adding activity instead of implementation.
3. 70% Disconnection
Stakeholders who feel unheard in top-down strategy processes. When people aren't meaningfully engaged in creating the strategy, they disengage from implementing it.
The Friction: Strategies that fail to get implemented because stakeholders don't feel ownership.
How Command-and-Control Creates the Spiral
The Overheating Spiral is created by command-and-control approaches to strategy development:
Command-and-Control Characteristics:
- Top-down decision-making
- Hierarchical approval processes
- Batch-and-queue workflows
- Separation of planning from execution
How It Creates Friction:
- Top-Down: Stakeholders don't feel heard → resistance
- Hierarchical: Multiple approval layers → delays
- Batch-and-Queue: Waiting between steps → waste
- Separation: Disconnect between strategy and implementation → failure
The Spiral:
- Friction creates delays
- Delays create frustration
- Frustration creates resistance
- Resistance creates more friction
- Result: Self-reinforcing cycle that gets worse over time
The Failure Demand Problem
Command-and-control creates failure demand: work that wouldn't be necessary if the process worked properly.
Examples of Failure Demand:
- Extra meetings to address stakeholder concerns
- Additional reviews because feedback wasn't incorporated
- Revisions because the strategy doesn't fit reality
- Implementation support because the strategy isn't clear
The Cost: Failure demand consumes 60-70% of strategy development time, creating the £80,000 waste.
Breaking the Spiral
Breaking the Overheating Spiral requires changing the approach:
From: Command-and-control To: Co-creation and collaboration
From: Top-down strategy development To: Stakeholder engagement from the start
From: Batch-and-queue processes To: Real-time collaboration
From: Separation of planning and execution To: Integrated strategy and implementation
How Insight Genie Helps
Insight Genie helps break the Overheating Spiral by providing visibility into where friction occurs:
Speedy Intelligence:
- Identifies friction points in days rather than months
- Reveals where the spiral is occurring
- Shows where interventions will have the most impact
Targeted Intervention:
- Focus on the friction points that matter most
- Measure the impact of changes
- Continuously improve the process
The Result: Break the spiral at its source, not just manage symptoms.
How Dynamic Genie Breaks the Spiral
Dynamic Genie breaks the Overheating Spiral by compressing strategy development from 8 months to 1 day:
Co-Creation Approach:
- All stakeholders together from the start
- Real-time collaboration eliminates batch-and-queue waste
- Immediate output eliminates delays
- Built-in ownership eliminates resistance
The Result: No time for the spiral to develop because the process is complete in one day.
How Meeting Genie Prevents Re-Overheating
Meeting Genie prevents re-overheating during implementation by maintaining flow:
Flow-Based Decision-Making:
- Meetings that produce decisions
- No circular discussions
- Clear path from discussion to action
- Result: Implementation moves forward instead of stalling
The Result: The spiral doesn't restart during implementation because flow is maintained.
The Transformation Trilogy
The Transformation Trilogy, Insight Genie, Dynamic Genie, and Meeting Genie, works together to break the Overheating Spiral:
Insight Genie: Reveals where friction occurs Dynamic Genie: Breaks the spiral in strategy development Meeting Genie: Prevents re-overheating in implementation
Together: Complete solution to the Overheating Spiral problem.
Conclusion
The Overheating Spiral explains why NHS strategy development consistently fails despite good intentions. Command-and-control approaches create friction, which slows progress, which creates more friction, until the process itself becomes the problem.
Breaking the spiral requires changing the approach: from command-and-control to co-creation, from top-down to stakeholder engagement, from batch-and-queue to real-time collaboration.
The Transformation Trilogy provides a complete solution: Insight Genie to reveal friction, Dynamic Genie to break the spiral, and Meeting Genie to prevent re-overheating.
If you're caught in an Overheating Spiral, book a discovery call to learn how we can help you break free.
Related Reading: