Why NHS Strategy Documents Fail (And How to Fix Them)
Understanding why professionally written strategies fail to drive change
Why NHS Strategy Documents Fail (And How to Fix Them)
NHS strategy documents often look professionally written. They have executive summaries, clear objectives, and polished language. But despite their professional appearance, they fail to drive change. Understanding why they fail is the first step to fixing the problem.
The Failure Pattern
The failure pattern is consistent:
The Development:
- Professional writing
- Clear objectives
- Polished language
- Executive approval
The Implementation:
- Document sits on shelf
- Initiatives don't get started
- Resources allocated but not used
- Frustration and cynicism
The Result: Strategies that look good but don't drive change.
Why They Fail
NHS strategy documents fail for three critical reasons:
1. Lack of Ownership
Frankenstein Documents are assembled by committee, so no one truly owns them. Each contributor added their piece, but no one feels responsible for the whole.
The Problem: When implementation begins, everyone points to someone else's section as the problem. No one drives implementation forward with genuine commitment.
The Result: Implementation stalls because no one owns it.
2. Disconnected from Reality
Strategy documents are often written in isolation from the people who will implement them. The language is abstract, the goals are aspirational, but the connection to day-to-day work is missing.
The Problem: Frontline staff can't see how the strategy relates to their work, so they ignore it.
The Result: Strategies that sit on shelves because they don't connect to reality.
3. Competing Priorities
When multiple stakeholders contribute, they often have competing priorities. The document tries to accommodate everyone, resulting in a strategy that says everything and nothing.
The Problem: The strategy lacks focus and clear direction, making it impossible to prioritize actions.
The Result: Strategies that fail because they try to do everything and accomplish nothing.
The Root Cause: The Overheating Spiral
These failures are symptoms of the Overheating Spiral:
The Spiral:
- Command-and-control approach creates friction
- Friction slows progress
- Slow progress creates more friction
- The spiral continues
The Symptoms:
- Frankenstein Documents that no one owns
- £80,000 wasted on non-value-adding activity
- 70% disconnection among stakeholders
The Result: Strategies that fail despite professional writing.
How to Fix Them
Fixing strategy document failure requires changing the approach:
1. Co-Creation Instead of Consultation
The Problem: Consultation creates disconnection because stakeholders don't feel ownership.
The Solution: Co-creation brings stakeholders together to create the strategy, not just comment on it.
The Result: Strategies that everyone owns because everyone created them.
2. Real-Time Collaboration Instead of Batch-and-Queue
The Problem: Batch-and-queue processes create waste and delays.
The Solution: Real-time collaboration compresses time and eliminates waste.
The Result: 8 months compressed to 1 day while improving quality.
3. Integration Instead of Separation
The Problem: Separation of planning and execution creates disconnect.
The Solution: Integrated strategy and implementation planning.
The Result: Strategies ready for immediate implementation.
The Dynamic Genie Solution
Dynamic Genie fixes strategy document failure by:
Co-Creation:
- All stakeholders together from the start
- Everyone participates in creating the strategy
- Built-in ownership from the start
Real-Time Collaboration:
- Compresses 8 months to 1 day
- Eliminates waste and delays
- Immediate output
Integration:
- Strategy and implementation planned together
- Ready for immediate implementation
- No disconnect between planning and execution
The Result: Strategies that are owned, connected to reality, and ready for implementation.
The Fix Results
Organizations using Dynamic Genie report:
Ownership:
- 100% stakeholder engagement
- Everyone owns the strategy because they created it
- Implementation driven forward with commitment
Reality Connection:
- Strategies that connect to day-to-day work
- Clear action items and next steps
- Implementation roadmap that makes sense
Focus:
- Clear priorities and direction
- Strategies that accomplish specific goals
- Measurable outcomes
Implementation Success:
- Strategies that actually get implemented
- Resources used effectively
- Value delivered
Conclusion
NHS strategy documents fail not because they're poorly written, but because they're created through processes that create disconnection, waste, and lack of ownership. The Overheating Spiral creates these problems, so fixing them requires breaking the spiral.
The solution is co-creation: bringing stakeholders together to create strategies in real-time, ensuring everyone owns the result and understands how to implement it.
If you're tired of strategy documents that sit on shelves, Dynamic Genie can help you create strategies that actually drive change.
Related Reading: